'ESCAPE CLAUSE' IN INTERNATIONAL FAMILY, PROPERTY AND SUCCESSION LAW
2025, 107, No. 1
University of Economics in Cracow, Jagiellonian University in Cracow, Department of Civil, Commercial, and Private International Law, Center for Private International Law
University of Economics in Cracow
Publication date
Publishing model
License type
Field
Discipline
Language of publication
Downloads
PDF 573 KB
Number of views:50
Number of downloads:51
Crossref citations:0
Altmetric score:0
Abstract
This article discusses the regulation of the escape clause in private international family, property and succession law from the perspective of the jurisdiction of a Polish court or other authority, like a notary public. In cases concerning family, property and succession, the predictability of the applicable law is of particular importance as private laws in those matters differ in substantial way from one country to another. Whereas the escape clause exceptionally allows the court for the a posteriori application of the law more closely connected or at least substantially connected to the case which can create a situation of uncertainty of applicable law for the involved parties. The functioning of the escape clause in the family (parental responsibility and maintenance), property (transit goods) and succession private international law is analysed in this article. The common features and the particularities of the legal regulation are presented. First, the law that is manifestly more closely connected to the case, no matter if family, property or succession, is indicated on the basis of all circumstances of the case and not only one (or two), as is the case in the indication of law on the basis of the connecting factor. Those circumstances are different depending on the hypothesis of the legal norm (e.g., different for transit goods than for the succession case), the wording of the escape clause and are estimated by the court a posteriori on the basis of all facts of the case. Second, the application of the escape clause is excluded if there is a choice of law (although in some cases parties are not allowed to choose law, e.g., for transit of goods or parental responsibility). Third, the escape clause is applicable exceptionally, as it introduces the uncertainty of law. Fourth, the escape clause is not regulated uniformly in international family, property and succession law. Moreover, the article presents how values such as legal certainty and flexibility are balanced by the legal regulation of the escape clause in family, property and succession private international law in order to indicate the law most closely related to a given relationship.
Keywords:
Bibliography
Abarca Junco AP and others (eds), Derecho International Privado, Madrid 2016
Arminjon P, Précis de Droit international privé, Vol 2, Paris 1958
Bar v C, Theorie und Praxis des International en Privatrechs, 1889, Vol 1
Bartin E-A, Principes de Droit International Privé, 1935, Vol 3
Baruffi MC, The 1996 Hague Convention on the Protection of Children, in I Viarengo, FC Villata (eds), Planning the Future of Cross-Border Families. A Path Through Coordination, Series: Studies in private international law Vol 29, Hart, Oxford, London, New York, New Delhi, Sydney 2020
Basedow J and others (eds), Encyclopedia of Private International Law, Vol 1, Cheltenham, Northampton 2017
Bonomi A, Wautelet P (eds), Le droit européen des successions. Commentaire du Règlement nº 650/2012 du 4 juillet 2012, Bruxelles, 2013
Bonomi A, The Hague Protocol of 23 November 2007 on the Law Applicable to Maintenance Obligations, Yearbook of Private International Law Vol 10, 2008
Bucher A, L’enfant en droit international privé, Genève-Bâle-Paris 2003
Calvo Caravaca A-L, General Rule, in A-L Calvo Caravaca, A Davì, H-P Mansel (eds), The EU Succession Regulation. A Commentary, Cambridge University Press 2016
Devers A, Rein-Lescastereyres I, Nato-Kaltane R, Loi applicable à la responsabilité parentale, in P Murat (ed), Droit de la famille 2016-2017, Paris 2016
Dörner H, EuErbVO: Die Verordnung zum Internationalen Erb- und Erbverfahrensrecht ist in Kraft!, ‘Zeitschrift für Erbrecht und Vermögensnachfolge’, 2012
Drozd E, Kolizyjna problematyka rzeczy w transporcie, Krakowskie Studia Prawnicze 1979
Dutta A, Commentary to EuErbVO Article 21 Allgemeine Kollisionsnorm, in Münchener Kommentar zum BGB, 8. Auflage 2020
Ernst U, Das polnische IPR-Gesetz von 2011 – Mitgliedstaaliche Rekodifikation in Zeiten supranationaler Kompetenzwahrnehmung, Rabels Zeitschrift für ausländisches und internationales Privatrecht 2012, Vol 76, No 3
Erp Van S, Comparative Property Law, in M Reimann, R Zimmermann (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Law, Oxford 2019
Fernández Rozas JC, Sánchez Lorenzo S, Derecho International Privado, Cizur Menor (Navarra) 2022
Frankenstein E, Internationales Privatrecht, 1929, Vol 2
Goldstein G, Objective, subjective and imperative localization in the resolution of conflict of laws, Yearbook of Private International Law Vol 24, 2022/2023
Górecki J, Prawa rzeczowe na rzeczy w transporcie z perspektywy kolizyjnej [Property rights on the transit good from comparative perspective], in E Figura-Góralczyk and others (eds), Prawne zagadnienia międzynarodowego obrotu cywilnego i handlowego [Legal issues of international civil and commercial relationships], Warsaw 2023
Greeske M, Die Kollisionsnormen der neuen EU-Erbrechtsverordnung, in R Hausmann, A Stadler, M Stürner (eds), Schriften zum internationalen Privat- und Verfahrensrecht, Band 17, Frankfurt am Main 2014
Hellendall F, The res in transitu and Similar Problems in the Conflict of Laws, in JM Carruthers (ed), Transfer of property and private international law, Volume I, Cheltenham, UK; Northampton, MA, USA : 2016
Kieninger E-M, Property Law (International), point 3 Special rules, <https://max-eup2012.mpipriv.de/index.php/Property_Law_(International)> accessed 27 July 2025
Kindler P, The law applicable to the succession objective connecting factors, in S Bariatti, I Viarengo, FC Villata (eds), EU Cross-Border Succession Law, Cheltenham, Northampton 2022
Kohler C, Pintens W, Entwicklungen im europäischen Familienund Erbrecht 2011-2012, ‘Zeitschrift für das gesamte Familienrecht 2012 No 18
Kruczalak K, Prawa rzeczowe w ustawie o prawie prywatnym międzynarodowym [Property rights in Private International Law Act], Kwartalnik Prawa Prywatnego 2000, issue 3
Kunz L, Die neue Europaische Erbrechtsverordnung - ein Uberblick (Teil I), Zeitschrift für das Privatrecht der Europäischen Union 2012 No 4
Lagarde P, Explanatory Report on the 1996 Hague Child Protection Convention, in Hague Conference on Private International Law, Proceedings of the Eighteenth Session, 30 September to 10 October 1996, Vol II, Protection of children, Hague 1998
Lagarde P, Les principes de base du nouveau règlement européen sur les successions, ‘Revue critique de droit international privé’ 2012 No 4
Mączyński A, Kodyfikacyjne zagadnienia części ogólnej prawa prywatnego międzynarodowego [Codification issues of the general part of Private International Law], in A Janik (ed), Studia i Rozprawy. Księga jubileuszowa dedykowana profesorowi Andrzejowi Całusowi [Studies and Dissertations. Anniversary book dedicated to Professor Andrzej Całus], Warsaw 2009
Mostowik P (ed), Międzynarodowe prawo rodzinne. Filiacja. Piecza nad dzieckiem. Alimentacja [International family law. Filiation. Childcare. Maintenance], Warsaw 2023
Mostowik P (ed), Prawo właściwe dla rozwodu i separacji w świetle rozporządzenia unijnego nr 1259/2010 [The law applicable to divorce and separation in the light of EU Regulation No. 1259/2010], Kwartalnik Prawa Prywatnego 2011, issue 2
Mostowik P (ed), Władza rodzicielska i opieka nad dzieckiem w prawie prywatnym międzynarodowym [Parental authority and child custody in Private International Law], Kraków 2014
Niboyet JP, Des conflits de lois rélatifs à l’acquisition de la propriété et des droits sur les meubles corporels à titre particulier, Recueil Sirey, 1912
Osajda K (ed), Rozporządzenie Parlamentu Europejskiego i Rady (UE) Nr 650/2012 z dnia 4 lipca 2012 r. w sprawie jurysdykcji, prawa właściwego, uznawania i wykonywania orzeczeń, przyjmowania i wykonywania dokumentów urzędowych dotyczących dziedziczenia oraz w sprawie ustanowienia europejskiego poświadczenia spadkowego. Komentarz [Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 4 July 2012 on jurisdiction, applicable law, recognition and enforcement of decisions and acceptance and enforcement of authentic instruments in matters of succession and on the creation of a European Certificate of Succession. Commentary], Warsaw 2019
Pazdan M (ed), Prawo prywatne międzynarodowe. Komentarz [Private International Law. Commentary], Warsaw 2018
Pazdan M (ed), System prawa prywatnego. Prawo prywatne międzynarodowe [System of Private Law. Private International Law], Vol 20B, Warsaw 2015
Pazdan M (ed), System prawa prywatnego. Prawo prywatne międzynarodowe [System of Private Law. Private International Law], Vol 20C, Warsaw 2015
Pilich M, Zasada obywatelstwa w prawie prywatnym międzynarodowym. Zagadnienia podstawowe [The principle of citizenship in private international law. Basic issues], Warsaw 2015
Poczobut J (ed) Prawo prywatne międzynarodowe. Komentarz [Private International Law. Commentary], Warsaw 2017
Rzewuski M, Transmisja spadku [Transmission of Inheritance], Wolters Kluwer 2016
Scherpe JM, Comparative Family Law, in M Reimann, R Zimmermann (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Law, Oxford 2019
Schnitzer A, Handbuch des Internstionales Privarrecht, 1937
Twardoch P, Nowe rumuńskie prawo prywatne międzynarodowe [New Romanian Private International Law], Problemy Prawa Prywatnego Międzynarodowego 2013 Vol 13
Volmer M, Die EU-Erbrechtsverordnung – erste Fragen an Dogmatik und Forensik, Rechtspfleger 2013
Waal De MJ, Comparative Succession Law, in M Reimann, R Zimmermann (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Law, Oxford 2019
Weil H, Die Kollisionsrechtliche Beurteilung von Tatbeständen des Sachenrechts in Beziehung auf res in transitu, Berlin 1933
Wojewoda M, Jurysdykcja krajowa i prawo właściwe w sprawach dotyczących stosunków między rodzicami a dziećmi – studium przypadku w relacjach Polska-USA [National jurisdiction and applicable law in matters relating to relations between parents and children - a case study in Poland-USA relations], Europejski Przegląd Sądowy 2018, No 4
Załucki M (ed), Unijne rozporządzenie spadkowe Nr 650/2012. Komentarz [EU Inheritance Regulation No 650/2012. Commentary], Warsaw 2018
Other articles from the issue
Content
- international protection of cultural heritageindividual criminal responsibilityUNESCOCouncil of EuropeEuropean Unioncultural propertycriminal sanctionsadministrative sanctionsimprisonmentconfiscation of property
PUNISHMENT IN CASES OF OFFENCES AGAINST CULTURAL HERITAGE. MODEL REMARKS AGAINST THE BACKGROUND OF UNESCO AND THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE CONVENTIONS
Anna Gerecka-Żołyńska
- prosecuting authoritiesassistancestate authoritieslocal government institutions
OBLIGATION OF STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT INSTITUTIONS TO PROVIDE ASSISTANCE TO AUTHORITIES CONDUCTING CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS (ARTICLE 15 § 2 OF THE CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE)
Sławomir Żółtek, Wojciech Jasiński, Jacek Kosonoga
Similar publications
03.02.2024
building structureprotection of third-party interestsconstruction worksusemaintenancePROTECTION OF THIRD-PARTY INTERESTS IN PROCEEDINGS CONCERNING BUILDING STRUCTURE MAINTENANCE IN POLISH CONSTRUCTION LAW
Artur Kosicki
29.02.2024
divorceparental responsibilityshared residencechild custodyLEGAL AND PSYCHOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVES ON PARENTAL RESPONSIBILITY AND SHARED RESIDENCE AFTER DIVORCE
Katarzyna Kamińska
01.02.2025
Private International LawPolish-Ukrainian Convention of 1993non-contractual obligationsbilateral agreementmaterial scopescope of applicationCONFLICT-OF-LAW ISSUES OF NON-CONTRACTUAL OBLIGATIONS IN POLISH-UKRAINIAN RELATIONS
Edyta Figura-Góralczyk