Studia Iuridica

ENFORCEMENT OF NEGOTIATED AND MEDIATED SETTLEMENTS IN THE EU AND IN THE ANGLOSPHERE: A COMPARATIVE APPROACH

2026, 111, No. 1

Piotr Sławicki

0000-0003-4570-9366

John Paul II Catholic University of Lublin

Stephen Ware

0000-0002-7994-9731

University of Kansas

DOI

10.31338/2544-3135.si.2026-111.4

Publication date

11.08.2026

Publishing model

open access

License type

CC BY 4.0 Int.

Field

Social sciences

Discipline

law

Language of publication

English

Downloads

PDF 455 KB

Article

Number of views:4

Number of downloads:3

Crossref citations:0

Altmetric score:0

Abstract

This article compares enforcement of negotiated and mediated settlements across members of the EU and the ‘Anglosphere’. While both EU and Anglosphere jurisdictions tend to treat a negotiated settlement as a contract the parties can, jointly with the court, transform into an enforceable court order, a practice in Anglo but not civil law is a court order permanently dismissing a case pursuant to a settlement the court does not see. Moreover, EU and Anglo countries tend to have greater differences in relation to mediated settlements. Anglo courts tend to treat them similarly to negotiated settlements, while some EU countries make it easier for parties to obtain court approval of a mediated settlement than a negotiated settlement. The article begins with the enforceability of negotiated settlements as contracts and then compares methods of making negotiated settlements as enforceable as court orders. It then compares Anglo treatment of mediated settlements largely as negotiated settlements with EU jurisdictions that provide a separate right to enforce mediated settlements. Finally, it shows how contrasting Anglo and EU approaches to mediated settlements emerged in Brexit and the Singapore Convention.

Keywords:

Alternative Dispute Resolution,negotiation,mediation,release,negotiated settlement,mediated settlement,enforcement of negotiated settlement,enforcement of mediated settlement,approval of negotiated settlement,approval of mediation settlement,settlement,amicable settlement,court settlement

Bibliography

Albers P, ‘The Netherlands’, in G de Palo, Mary B Trevor (eds), EU Mediation. Law and Practice (Oxford University Press 2012)

Aleksandrova S, ‘Bulgaria’, in G de Palo, Mary B Trevor (eds), EU Mediation. Law and Practice (Oxford University Press 2012)

Ali SF, ‘Court Mediation Reform: Efficiency, Confidence and Perceptions of Justice’ (2018) 021 University of Hong Kong Faculty of Law Legal Studies Research Paper Series

Allen T, ‘The Place of Mediation in England and Wales’ (2014) 25(4) European Business Law Review Anzenberger Ph, ‘The European Dimension of Court Settlements: Open Issues and Regulatory Needs’ in V Rijavec and others (eds), Diversity of Enforcement Titles in EU (Springer 2023)

Benham DB, ‘Foundational and Contemporary Court Confidentiality’ (2021) 86 Mo. L. Rev. Betto JG, Canivet A, ‘France’, in G de Palo, MB Trevor (eds), EU Mediation. Law and Practice (Oxford University Press 2012)

Bertolini D, ‘Releasing the Unknown: Theoretical and Evidentiary Challenges in Interpreting the Release of Unanticipated Claims’ (2023) 48(2) Queen’s Law Journal <https://canlii.ca/t/7n6jl> accessed 29 April 2025

Bokwa K, ‘Anwaltsvergleich – niemiecka ugoda adwokacka jako wzór dla polskiego ustawodawcy?’ (2018) 3 Kwartalnik ADR. Arbitraż i Mediacja

Bowden C, Financial Consent Orders in Mediation (17 January 2022) <https://anthonygold.co.uk/insight/financial-consent-orders-mediation/> accessed 30 June 2025

Britton P, ‘Tomlin Orders: When Are They Used?’ (2 February 2022) <https://brittontime.com/insights/tomlin-orders/> accessed 30 June 2025

Buhigues JLI, Moreno GP, Calabuig RE, Monzonís CA, ‘Spain’, in C Esplugues (ed), Civil and Commercial Mediation in Europe. Cross-Border Mediation. Volume II (Intersentia 2014)

Capelo MJ, ‘La Médiation, une Autre Voie de Justice au Portugal?’ in C Esplugues, L Marquis (eds), New Developments in Civil and Commercial Mediation. Global Comparative Perspectives (Springer 2015)

Chang YC, Klerman D, ‘Settlement Around the World: Settlement Rates in the Largest Economies’ (2022) 14(1) Journal of Legal Analysis 80–175 Chitty on Contracts, ch. 26–109 (35th edn, Sweet & Maxwell 2025)

https://doi.org/10.1093/jla/laac006

Chong Ph, Tout E, United Kingdom in John Fellas, Transnational Litigation (2024)

Ciucă AE, Gavrilă CA, ‘Romania’, in G de Palo, MB Trevor (eds), EU Mediation. Law and Practice (Oxford University Press 2012)

Cole SR and others, Mediation: Law, Policy, & Practice (Thomson Reuters 2024)

Deason EE, ‘What’s in A Name? The Terms “Commercial” and “Mediation” in the Singapore Convention on Mediation’ (2019) 20 Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution DiSarro A, ‘Six Decrees of Separation: Settlement Agreements and Consent Orders in Federal Civil Litigation’ (2010) 60(2) American University Law Review Dulęba D, Ugoda w polskim prawie cywilnym (1st edn, LexisNexis 2012)

Elliott R, ‘The Eviction Crisis is Rampaging’ (2025) 1 Journal of Dispute Resolution Emilianides AC, Charalampidou N, ‘Cyprus’, in C Esplugues (ed), Civil and Commercial Mediation in Europe. Cross-Border Mediation, Volume II (Intersentia 2014)

Esplugues C, ‘Mediation in the EU After the Transposition of the Directive 2008/52/EC on Mediation in Civil and Commercial Matters’, in C Esplugues (ed), Civil and Commercial Mediation in Europe. Cross-Border Mediation, Volume II (Intersentia 2014)

Galanter M, Cahill M, ‘“Most Cases Settle”: Judicial Promotion and Regulation of Settlements’ (1994) 46(6) Stanford Law Review Ginter C, ‘Estonia’, in G de Palo, MB Trevor (eds), EU Mediation. Law and Practice (Oxford University Press 2012)

Gmurzyńska E, Morek R, ‘Poland’, in G de Palo, MB Trevor (eds), EU Mediation. Law and Practice (Oxford University Press 2012)

Gruber UP, Bach I, ‘Germany’, in C Esplugues (ed), Civil and Commercial Mediation in Europe. Cross-Border Mediation, Volume II (Intersentia 2014)

Hylton KN, ‘Selling Out: An Instrumentalist Theory of Legal Ethics’ (2021) 34(19) The Georgetown Journal of Legal Ethics Keller LR, ‘Malta’, in G de Palo, M B Trevor (eds), EU Mediation. Law and Practice (Oxford University Press 2012)

Kolber J, ‘Mediacja – Francja, Belgia’, in Andrzej Torbus (ed), Mediacja w sprawach gospodarczych. Praktyka – teoria – perspektywy (Ministerstwo Gospodarki 2015)

Lambert D, ‘Mediation in United Kingdom’ (9 September 2019) Lexology <https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=02ee5416-79ba-484b-bd62-eb26318d330b> accessed 30 June 2025

Lopes D, ‘Portugal’, in Carlos Esplugues (ed), Civil and Commercial Mediation in Europe. Cross-Border Mediation, Volume II (Intersentia 2014)

Luca De A, ‘Mediation in Italy: Features and Trends’, in C Esplugues, L Marquis (eds), New Developments in Civil and Commercial Mediation. Global Comparative Perspectives (Springer 2015)

Maciejewski M, ‘Polish Regulation Model of Civil Court Mediation and Assessment of Its Effectiveness’ (2024) 16(4) Krytyka Prawa. Niezależne studia nad prawem Majoli L, ‘L’esecuzione dell’accordo in mediazione’ (ADR Intesa 2021) <https://www.adrintesa.it/esecuzione-accordo-in-mediazione> accessed 2 May 2025

Marinari M, ‘Italy’, in G de Palo, MB Trevor (eds), EU Mediation. Law and Practice (Oxford University Press 2012)

Menétrey S, ‘La Médiation à la Croisée des Frontières: Le cas Luxembourgeois’ in C Esplugues, L Marquis (eds), New Developments in Civil and Commercial Mediation. Global Comparative Perspectives (Springer 2015)

Menétrey S, ‘Luxembourg’, in C Esplugues (ed), Civil and Commercial Mediation in Europe. Cross-Border Mediation, Volume II (Intersentia 2014)

Milu RG, Taus M, ‘Romania’, in Carlos Esplugues (ed), Civil and Commercial Mediation in Europe. Cross-Border Mediation, Volume II (Intersentia 2014)

Monzonís CA, Redondo PQ, ‘Mediation in Spain: Novelties Derived from the Boost of the European Legislator’, in C Esplugues, L Marquis (eds), New Developments in Civil and Commercial Mediation. Global Comparative Perspectives (Springer 2015)

Okońska A, ‘Mediacja – Austria, Niemcy, Szwajcaria’, in A Torbus (ed), Mediacja w sprawach gospodarczych. Praktyka – teoria – perspektywy (Ministerstwo Gospodarki 2015)

Queirolo I, Gambino Ch, ‘Italy’, in C Esplugues (ed), Civil and Commercial Mediation in Europe. Cross-Border Mediation, Volume II (Intersentia 2014)

Resnik J, ‘The Privatization of Process: Requiem for and Celebration of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure’ (2014) 162 U. Pa. L. Rev.

Rützel S and others, Commercial Dispute Resolution in Germany (2nd edn, C.H.Beck 2016)

Schnabel T, ‘The Singapore Convention on Mediation: A Framework for the Cross-Border Recognition and Enforcement of Mediated Settlements’ (2019) 19 Pepperdine Dispute Resolution Law Journal

Şandru DM, Călin DA, ‘La Médiation en Roumanie la Médiation entre l’Habitude d’Avoir Recours au Système Traditionnel de Justice et le Remboursement de l’Intégralité des Frais de Justice’ in C Esplugues, L Marquis (eds), New Developments in Civil and Commercial Mediation. Global Comparative Perspectives (Springer 2015)

Sippel L, ‘Scandinavian Countries’, in C Esplugues (ed), Civil and Commercial Mediation in Europe. Cross-Border Mediation, Volume II (Intersentia 2014)

Smanio I, ‘Obowiązkowa mediacja we Włoszech’ (2020) 3 Kwartalnik ADR. Arbitraż i Mediacja

Taelman P, Voet S, ‘Mediation in Belgium: A Long and Winding Road’ in C Esplugues, L Marquis (eds), New Developments in Civil and Commercial Mediation. Global Comparative Perspectives (Springer 2015)

Taivalkoski P, ‘Finland’, in G de Palo, MB Trevor (eds), EU Mediation. Law and Practice (Oxford University Press 2012)

Taivalkoski P, Pynnä A, ‘The Courts and Bar Association as Drivers for Mediation in Finland’ in Carlos Esplugues, Louis Marquis (eds), New Developments in Civil and Commercial

Mediation. Global Comparative Perspectives (Springer 2015)

The Law Society, Alternative dispute resolution after Brexit (13 January 2021) <https://www.lawsociety.org.uk/topics/brexit/alternative-dispute-resolution-after-brexit> accessed 30 June 2025

Traest M, ‘Belgium’, in C Esplugues (ed), Civil and Commercial Mediation in Europe. Cross-Border Mediation, Volume II (Intersentia 2014)

Ware SJ, Principles of Alternative Dispute Resolution (4th edn, West Academic Publishing 2023)

Verougstraete I, ‘Belgium’, in G de Palo, MB Trevor (eds), EU Mediation. Law and Practice (Oxford University Press 2012)

Wright CA, Kane MK, Law of Federal Courts (8th edn, West Academic Publishing 2017)

Zachariasiewicz M, ‘Poland’, in C Esplugues (ed), Civil and Commercial Mediation in Europe. Cross-Border Mediation, Volume II (Intersentia 2014)

Similar publications