Oryginalny artykuł naukowy
Studia Iuridica

Dominion Voting Systems v Fox News Network: Defamation Actions as a Tool for the Rule of Law in Turbulent Times

2025, 106, Numer 1


Data publikacji

29.07.2025

Model publikowania

open access

Rodzaj licencji


Dziedzina

Prawo

Dyscyplina

nauki prawne

Klasyfikacja

-

Język publikacji

Angielski

Pliki do pobrania

PDF 433 KB

Artykuł

Liczba wyświetleń:156

Liczba pobrań:46

Cytowania Crossref:0

Wynik Altmetric:0

Zobacz mapę pobrań

Abstrakt

When we think about areas of law that are most essential to advancing the Rule of Law in turbulent times, constitutional law and its limits on the power of government might be the first thing that comes to mind. Injury or tort law is probably not at the top of the list. Yet the law of defamation, one type of tort law, arguably played a significant role in counteracting false statements about the 2020 Presidential Election in the United States, false statements that led to a violent assault on the U.S. Capitol. Dominion Voting Systems, the manufacturer of electronic voting machines, sued Fox News for defamation based on statements asserting that Dominion rigged the election and committed election fraud. After a judge rejected several of Fox’s main defenses raised in a summary judgment motion, Fox agreed to pay Dominion $787.5 million to settle the case. This Article explains the court’s summary judgment decision. It concludes by arguing that controversial aspects of U.S. defamation law – such as the high bar of the actual malice standard and the trend against recognizing the privilege of neutral reportage – helped advance the Rule of Law in this case.

Słowa kluczowe:

Bibliografia

Bunker M, 'Corporate Chaos: The Muddled Jurisprudence of Corporate Public Figures', 23 Comm. L. & Pol'y 1, (2018) https://doi.org/10.1080/10811680.2018.1406766

Cohen M & Darcy O, 'Fox News settles with Dominion at the last second, pays more than $787 million to avert defamation trial over its 2020 election lies', CNN.com, 19 April 2023, <https://www.cnn.com/2023/04/18/media/fox-dominion-settlement/> accessed 20 June 2025 Dobbs DB, The Law of Torts 1150 n.23 (2000)

Enrich D, 'Trump and His Picks Threaten More Lawsuits About Critical Coverage', New York Times, 14 December 2024, <https://www.nytimes.com/2024/12/15/business/ media/trump-defamation-lawsuit-abc- hegseth-cnn.html> accessed 20 June 2025

Feuer A, 'Dominion demands that Sidney Powell retract 'baseless and false allegations' about voting machines', New York Times, 17 December 2020, <https://www.nytimes. com/2020/12/17/us/dominion-demands-that-sidney-powell-retract-baseless-and-false-allegations-about-voting-machines.html> accessed 20 June 2025

First Amendment Watch, 'Trump Suing for Defamation', <https://firstamendmentwatch. org/tag/trump-suing-for-defamation/> accessed 11 March 2025 (listing the defamation lawsuits against media defendants filed by Donald Trump)

Freeman G, 'Long-Run Effects of Dominion v Fox', Media Law Resource Center, April 2023, <https://medialaw.org/long-run-effects-of-dominion-v-fox/> accessed 20 June 2025

Gersen JS, 'The Dark Side of Defamation Law', The New Yorker, 11 May 2023, <https:// www.newyorker.com/magazine/2023/05/22/the-dark-side-of-defamation-law> accessed 20 June 2025 31

Grynbaum, Michael M, 'Trump Renews Pledge to "Take a Strong Look" at Libel Laws', New York Times, 10 January 2018, <https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/10/business/ media/trump-libel-laws.html> accessed 20 June 2025

Gutterman RS, 'Actually … A Renewed Stand for the First Amendment Actual Malice Defense', 68 Syracuse L. Rev. 579 (2018)

Johnson VR, 'Comparative Defamation Law: England and the United States', 24 U. Miami Int'l & Comp. L. Rev. 1 (2017)

Kennedy M & Chappell B, 'Dominion Voting Systems Files $1.6 Billion Defamation Lawsuit Against Fox News', NPR.com, 26 March 2021, <https://www.npr. org/2021/03/26/981515184/dominion-voting-systems-files-1-6-billion-defamation-lawsuit-against-fox-news> accessed 20 June 2025

Kosseff J, 'What Protects Fox News Also Protects Our Democracy', New York Times, 14 April 2023, <https://www.nytimes.com/2023/04/14/opinion/dominion-fox-news-supreme-court-sullivan.html> accessed 20 June 2025

Laidman D, 'When the Slander Is the Story: The Neutral Reportage Privilege in Theory and Practice', 17 UCLA L. Rev. 74 (2010) https://doi.org/10.5070/LR8171027133

Lat D, 'Is Viet Dinh the Most Powerful Lawyer in America?', Original Jurisdiction, 17 March 2021, <https://davidlat.substack.com/p/is-viet-dinh-the-most-powerful-lawyer> accessed 20 June 2025

Lavi M, 'Publish, Share, Re-Tweet, and Repeat', 54 U. Mich. J.L. Reform 441 (2021) https://doi.org/10.36646/mjlr.54.2.publish

Levi L, 'Disinformation and the Defamation Renaissance: A Misleading Promise of "Truth'", 57 U. Rich. L. Rev. 1235 (2023)

Lewis JB & Oxley BL, 'New York Times v. Sullivan at 60: Where Does Defamation Law Go Now?', 73 DePaul L. Rev. 995 (2024)

Lidsky L, 'Cheap Speech and the Gordian Knot of Defamation Reform', 3 J. Free Speech L. 79 (2023) https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009174411.010

Logan DA, 'Rescuing Our Democracy by Rethinking New York Times v Sullivan', 81 Ohio St. L. J. 759 (2020)

Lucas R, 'Where the Jan. 6 insurrection investigation stands, one year later', NPR.org, 6 January 2022, <https://www.npr.org/2022/01/06/1070736018/jan-6-anniversary-investigation-cases-defendants-justice> accessed 20 June 2025

Mazzeo Ch, 'Neutral Reportage Privilege: The Libel Defense Needed in a Struggling Democracy', Master's Theses (2009-) 548, <https://epublications.marquette.edu/ theses_open/548> accessed 20 June 2025, 62

Orth T & Bialik C, 'Trust in Media 2024: Which news sources Americans trust - and which they think lean left or right', YouGov, 30 May 2024, <https://today.yougov. com/politics/articles/49552-trust-in-media-2024-which-news-outlets-americans-trust> accessed 20 June 2025

Peters JW, 'Judge Limits Fox's Options for Defense in Dominion Trial', New York Times, 11 April 2023, <https://www.nytimes.com/2023/04/11/business/fox-news-dominion-trial.html> accessed 20 June 2025

Restatement (Second) of Torts § 578 (1997)

Rosenfeld S, 'The Paper Case : The Neutral Reportage Privilege in Defamation Cases and Its Impact on the First Amendment', 19 Vill. Sports & Ent. L.J. 135 (2012)

Rutenberg J and others, К»77 Days: Trump's Campaign to Subvert the Election', New York Times, 31 January 2021, <https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/31/us/trump-election-lie.html> accessed 20 June 2025

Rutenberg J and others, '77 'Missteps and Miscalculations: Inside Fox's Legal and Busi-ness Debacle', New York Times, 27 May 2023, <https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/27/ business/media/fox-news-dominion-voting.html> accessed 20 June 2025

Sanders AK, 'Revisiting Rosenbloom: Can a Return to the 'Matter of Public Concern' Standard in Defamation Cases Quiet Sullivan Skeptics?', 88 Mo. L. Rev. 769 (2023)

Schwartz V and others, Prosser, Wade, and Schwartz's Torts Cases and Materials (2020)

Sosner N & Freeman G, 'The Neutral Reportage Doctrine: MIA. Doesn't Good Journalism Demand It?', 33-WTR Comm. Law 14 (2018)

Standen J, 'Republication Liability on the Web', 105 Marq. L. Rev. 669 (2022)

Tardi G, 'The Truth Shall Set Democracy Free', 18 J. Parliamentary & Pol. L. 1 (2024)

Taylor M, 'Fox News reaches $787.5 million settlement in Dominion's defamation lawsuit', Politico, 18 April 2023, <https://www.politico.com/news/2023/04/18/ fox-news-reaches-settlement-with-dominion-in-defamation-lawsuit-00092621> accessed 20 June 2025

Podobne publikacje