SOLVING THE “PROBLEM” OF WILLS FORMALITIES IN THE MODERN POST-PANDEMIC SOCIETY: CAN THE ENDLESS DISCUSSION BE CONCLUDED?
2021, 87, No. 1
AFM Kraków University
Publication date
Publishing model
License type
Field
Discipline
Language of publication
Downloads
PDF 506 KB
Number of views:344
Number of downloads:83
Crossref citations:0
Altmetric score:0
Abstract
The last will as an instrument of succession law is one of the means of disposing property upon death. Around the world particular legal regulations of American, Australian, European or other countries generally provide for different specific formal requirements for the valid preparation of will. The inappropriateness of this kind of solutions was shown, among others, during the COVID-19 pandemic, when the need for making last wills has increased significantly and has rarely been executed in a manner consistent with the formalities. Reflecting the intent of a testator, often expressed informally, seems to be a more important value of the law of succession than respecting the formalities. This has already been noticed in some countries, especially in common law jurisdictions in Australia and America, where solutions based on substantial compliance doctrine or its variations, contrary to the pan-European strict compliance standard, were adopted. These solutions, however, do not take into consideration plenty of circumstances that may occur in the testation practice and are indifferent to new possible ways of making wills. Meanwhile, the range of mechanisms and proposals for statutory changes in the area of wills formalities is constantly growing. However, there are no proposals to cover all possible legislations in this area, as regards Anglo-American, European or other countries. Yet such a solution seems possible and desirable in order to reconcile the doctrines of substantial compliance and strict compliance. This proposal is the subject of this study.
Keywords:
Bibliography
Baron J. B., Irresolute Testators, Clear and Convincing Wills Law, "Washington & Lee Law Review" 2016, Vol. 73
Beckert J., The Longue Durée of Inheritance Law. Discourses and Institutional Development in France, Germany, and the United States since 1800, "European Journal of Sociology" 2007, Vol. 48
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003975607000306
Beyer G. W., Hargrove C. G., Digital Wills: Has the Time Come for Wills to Join the Digital Revolution?, "Ohio NUL Review" 2007, Vol. 33
Binder J., Bürgerliches Recht. Erbrecht, Springer 1923
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-94199-3
Breitschmid P., Bericht zu den Konturen eines "zeitgemässen Erbrechts" zu Handen des Bundesamtes für Justiz zwecks Umsetzung der "Motion Gutzwiller", Sonderheft Not@lex/succesio 2014, Nr 7
Breitschmid P., Revision der Formvorschriften des Testaments - Bemerkungen zur Umsetzung der "Initiative Guinand", "Zeitschrift des Bernischen Juristenvereins" 1995, Vol. 3
Breitschmid P., Testament und Erbvertrag - Formprobleme: Die Einsatzmöglichkeiten für die Nachlassplanung im Lichte neuerer Rechtsentwicklungen, (in:) P. Breitschmid (ed.), Testament und Erbvertrag, Haupt 1991
Breuer A., Pellegrini v. Breitenbach. Power to Reform Innocent Mistakes in Wills, "Quinnipac Probate Law Journal" 2012, Vol. 26
Brown R. L., The Holograph Problem: The Case Against Holographic Wills, "Tennessee Law Review" 2005, Vol. 74
Bundesamt für Justiz, Vorentwurf und erläuternder Bericht zur Änderung des Zivilgesetzbuchs (Erbrecht), 2016
Burns F., Surviving Spouses, Surviving Children and the Reform of Total Intestacy Law in England and Scotland: Past, Present, and Future, "Legal Studies" 2013, Vol. 1
https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-121X.2012.00238.x
Cobas Cobiella M. E., Joz Latorre C. de, La modernización del derecho de sucesiones. Algunas propuestas, "Cuestiones de Interés Jurídico" 2007
Cottier M., Ein zeitgemässes Erbrecht für die Schweiz: Bericht zur Motion 10.3524 Gutzwiller "Für ein zeitgemässes Erbrecht" zuhanden des Bundesamtes für Justiz, Sonderheft Not@lex/succesio 2014
Crawford B. J., Wills Formalities in the Twenty-First Century, "Wisconsin Law Review" 2019, Vol. 2
Crawford B. J., Purser K., Cockburn T., Post-Pandemic Wills, University of Chicago Legal Forum 2021
https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3615151
Croucher R. F., Statutory Wills and Testamentary Freedom - Imagining the Testator's Intention in Anglo-Australian Law, "Oxford University Commonwealth Law Journal" 2007, Vol. 7
https://doi.org/10.1080/14729342.2007.11421484
Dunand J.-Ph., Le testament oral en droit suisse et dans l'ancien droit neuchâtelois, (in:) J. Kellerhals, D. Manaï, R. Roth (eds.), Pour un droit pluriel: Études offertes au Professeur Jean-François Perrin, Helbing & Lichtenhahn 2002
Dvoenosova G. A., The Functions of a Document, "Scientific and Technical Information Processing" 2013, Vol. 40
https://doi.org/10.3103/S014768821301005X
Echeverría J. D., ¿Qué reformas cabe esperar en el derecho de sucesiones del Código Civil? (Un ejercicio de prospectiva), "El Cronista del Estado Social y Democrático de Derecho" 2009
Erp S. van, New Developments in Succession Law, "Electronic Journal of Comparative Law" 2007, No. 11
Evans S., Testators' Wishes; Dead or Alive: Is There a Difference? "The Conveyancer and Property Lawyer" 2013
Fernández F. R., El testamento y la futura reforma del código civil en materia de discapacidad: Algunas reflexiones, "Actualidad Jurídica Iberoamericana" 2009, Vol. 10
Foster F. H., Dark Side of Trusts: Challenges to Chinese Inheritance Law, "The Washington University Global Studies Law Review" 2003, Vol. 2
Giesen D., BGB Allgemeiner Teil: Rechtsgeschäftslehre, De Gruyter 1995
https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110904161
Glover M., The Therapeutic Function of Testamentary Formality, "Kansas Law Review" 2012, Vol. 61
Grant J. K., Shattering and Moving Beyond the Gutenberg Paradigm: The Dawn of the Electronic Will, "University of Michigan Journal of Law Reform" 2008, Vol. 42
Grundmann S., Favor Testamenti: Zu Formfreiheit und Formzwang bei privatschriftlichen Testamenten, "Archiv Für Die Civilistische Praxis" 1987, Vol. 187
Grzybowski S. (ed.), System prawa cywilnego. Część ogólna, Vol. I, Ossolineum 1985
Gulliver A. G., Tilson C. J., Classification of Gratuitous Transfers, "Yale Law Journal" 1941, Vol. 51
https://doi.org/10.2307/792342
Haines D., Informal Wills and the Uniform Legislation, The Law Society of South Australia Succession Law Conference 2007, The Law Society of Australia 2007
Hedlund R., Introducing a Dispensing Power in English Succession Law, "Trusts & Trustees" 2019, Vol. 25
https://doi.org/10.1093/tandt/ttz059
Heinrich D., Schwab D. (eds.), Familienerbrecht und Testierfreiheit im Europäischen Vergleich, Verlag Gieseking 2001
Heiss H., Formmängel und ihre Sanktionen: Eine privatrechtsvergleichende Untersuchung, Mohr Siebeck 1999
Hirsch A. J., Technology Adrift: In Search of a Role for Electronic Wills, "Boston College Law Review" 2020, Vol. 61
Horton D., Weisbord R.K., COVID-19 and Formal Wills, "Stanford Law Review Online" 2020, No. 1
https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3572097
Hurlburt W. H., Electronic Wills and Powers of Attorney: Has Their Day Come?, The Uniform Law Conference of Canada, Proceedings of 83rd Annual Meeting, The Uniform Law Conference of Canada 2001
Kennedy D., From the Will Theory to the Principle of Private Autonomy: Lon Fuller's "Consideration and Form", "Columbia Law Review" 2000, Vol. 100
https://doi.org/10.2307/1123557
Kerridge R., Brierley A., Parry D. H., Parry and Kerridge: The Law of Succession, 13th edn., Sweet & Maxwell 2016
Langbein J. H., Absorbing South Australia's Wills Act Dispensing Power in the United States: Emulation, Resistance, Expansion, "Adelaide Law Review" 2017, Vol. 38
Langbein J. H., Excusing Harmless Errors in the Execution of Wills: A Report on Australia's Tranquil Revolution in Probate Law, "Columbia Law Review" 1987, Vol. 87
Langbein J. H., Substantial Compliance with the Wills Act, "Harvard Law Review" 1975, Vol. 88
https://doi.org/10.2307/1340322
Lange K. W., Erbrecht, C.H. Beck 2017
Law Reform Commission of Saskatchewan, Report on Electronic Wills, 2004
Mann B. H., Formalities and Formalism in the Uniform Probate Code, "University of Pennsylvania Law Review" 1994, Vol. 142
https://doi.org/10.2307/3312502
McNary A., The New Alberta Wills and Succession Act - What's In It?... And What's Out, Legal Education Society of Alberta 2011
Melnychuk K. S., One Click Away: The Prospect of Electronic Wills in Saskatchewan, "Saskatchewan Law Review" 2014, Vol. 77
Miller G., Reforming the Formal Requirements for the Execution of a Will, "Denning Law Journal" 1993, Vol. 8
https://doi.org/10.5750/dlj.v8i1.235
Miller G., The Machinery of Succession, Darmouth 1996
Muscheler K., Das eigenhändige Testament - gestern, heute und morgen, "Successio - Zeitchrift für Erbrecht" 2014, Vol. 1
Newbould J., Demand for Wills on the Rise as Coronavirus Fears Set in for Australians, "Money Magazine" 8 April 2020
Niedośpiał M., Testament. Zagadnienia ogólne testamentu w polskim prawie cywilnym, Kraków-Poznań 1993
Osajda K., Prawo spadkowe (w) przyszłości. Perspektywy rozwoju prawa spadkowego, "Monitor Prawniczy" 2019, Vol. 2
Pabin A., Testament jako akt sformalizowany - uwagi w sprawie przyszłego ksztaltu regulacji dotyczących formy rozrządzeń testamentowych, "Studia Prawnicze" 2016, Vol. 91
https://doi.org/10.37232/sp.2016.1.4
Peart N., New Zealand's Succession Law: Subverting Reasonable Expectations, "Common Law World Review" 2008, Vol. 37
https://doi.org/10.1350/clwr.2008.37.4.0178
Peart N., Where There Is a Will, There Is a Way - A New Wills Act for New Zealand, "Waikato Law Review" 2007, Vol. 15
Peart N., Kelly G., The Scope of the Validation Power in the Wills Act 2007, "New Zealand Law Review" 2013, Vol. 73
Ponath G., Die Beschränkungen der Testierfreiheit durch das Testamentsrecht, Zerb Verlag 2006
Pound R., The Role of the Will in Law, "Harvard Law Review" 1954, Vol. 68
https://doi.org/10.2307/1337499
Purser K., Cockburn T., Wills Formalities in the Twenty-First Century - Promoting Testamentary Intention in the Face of Societal Change and Advancements in Technology: An Australian Response to Professor Crawford, "Wisconsin Law Review Forward" 2019, Vol. 4
Purser K., Cockburn T., Crawford B. J., Wills Formalities Beyond COVID-19: An Australian-United States Perspective, "UNSW Law Journal Forum" 2020, Vol. 5
https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3720055
Reid K. G. C., De Waal M. J., Zimmermann R. (eds.), Comparative Succession Law. Testamentary Formalities, Oxford University Press 2011
https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199696802.001.0001
Richemont H. D., Projet de loi portant réforme des successions et des libéralités. Rapport No. 343, Sénat de la République Française 2006
Ripoll Soler A., Hacia un nuevo modelo de planificación sucesoria notarial: La professio iuris, "Revista de Derecho Civil" 2016, Vol. 3
Robleda O. SJ, La nulidad del acto ujurídico, Rome 1964
Röthel A., Ist unser Erbrecht noch zeitgemäß?, C.H. Beck 2010
Röthel A., Testamentsformen, "Juristische Ausbildung" 2014, Vol. 5
https://doi.org/10.1515/jura-2014-0055
Rudnicki J., Rola formy testamentu. Uwagi na tle porównawczym, "Forum Prawnicze" 2013, Vol. 2
Sagaut J.-F., Présentation de la loi réformant le droit français des liberalités et des successions, "Electronic Journal of Compartive Law" 2010
Sandoval J. S., El testamento ológrafo en soporte digital y la firma biométrica, "Boletín del Ministerio de Justicia" 2019, Nr 1
Sasso I., Will Formalities in the Digital Age: Some Comparative Remarks, "Italian Law Journal" 2018, Vol. 4
Scalise R. J. J., New Developments in United States Succession Law, "The American Journal of Comparative Law" 2006
https://doi.org/10.1093/ajcl/54.suppl1.103
Schmoeckel M., Otte G. (eds.), Europäische Testamentsformen, Nomos 2011
Siddique H., Video Witnessing of Wills to Be Made Legal in England and Wales During Pandemic, "The Guardian", 25 July 2020
Sitkoff R. H., Dukeminier J., Wills, Trusts and Estates, 10th edn., Wolters Kluwer 2017
Slingo J., Coronavirus: Demand for Wills Jumps by 76%, "The Law Society Gazette", 31 March 2020
Snail S., Hall N., Electronic Wills in South Africa, "Digital Evidence and Electronic Signature Law Review" 2010, Vol. 7
https://doi.org/10.14296/deeslr.v7i0.1925
Sonnekus J. C., Videotestamente naas skriftelike testamente, "Tydskrif vir die Suid-Afrikaanse Reg" 1990
Spitzer M., Neues zu letzwilligen Verfügunen. Ein Beitrag zu Nottestament und Testierfähigkeit, "Ӧsterreichische Notariats Zeitung" 2006, No. 14
Tamaruya M., Japanese Wealth Management and the Transformation of the Law of Trusts and Succession, "Trust Law International" 2019, Vol. 33
Toit F. Du, Testamentary Condonation in South Africa: A Pyrrhic Victory for Private Autonomy over Mandatory Formalism in the Law of Wills ?, (in:) A.-L. Verbeke [et al.] (eds.), Confronting the Frontiers of Family and Succession Law. Liber Amicorum Walter Pintens, Intersentia 2012
Tucker R. M., How Substantial Is Substantial ? Compliance with the Louisiana Civil Code's Requirements for Notarial Testaments, "Tulane Law Review" 2018, Vol. 92
Tudoraşcu M. M., The Testament under Romanian Civil Law Provisions, "AGORA International Journal of Juridical Sciences" 2016, Vol. 53
https://doi.org/10.15837/aijjs.v10i2.2839
Uzcategui J., Application of the Harmless Error Doctrine in California and Beyond, "California Trusts & Estates Quarterly" 2015, Vol. 21
Veloso Z., Testamentos - Nocoes Gerais, Formas ordinarias, (in:) D. Franciulli Netto, G. F. Mendes, I. G. da Silva Martins Filho (eds.), O novo Codigo Civil: Estudos em Homenagem ao Prof Miguel Reale, Sao Paulo, LTR 2003
Victorian Law Reform Commission, Succession Laws, 2013
Wang H., Galligan M. W., Kolodny J. B., Modern Inheritance Develops in China, "New York Law Journal" 2013, Vol. 2
Weisbord R. K., Horton D., Urice S. K., Wills, Trusts and Estates. The Essentials, Wolters Kluwer 2018
Welser R., Die Reform des österreichischen Erbrechts, "Österreichische Notariat Zeitung" 2012, No. 144
Welser R., Reformbedarf bei den letztwilligen Verfügungen, (in:) R. Geime, R. A. Schütze, T. Garber (eds.), Europä ische und internationale Dimension des Rechts: Festschrift fü r Daphne-Ariane Simotta, Lexis Nexis 2012
Wendel P. T., Wills Act Compliance and the Harmless Error Approach: Flawed Narrative Equals Flawed Analysis?, "Oregon Law Review" 2017, Vol. 95
Załucki M., Forma testamentu w perspektywie rekodyfikacji polskiego prawa spadkowego. Czas na rewolucję?, "Państwo i Prawo" 2017, Vol. 3
Załucki M., Preparation of Wills in Times of COVID-19 Pandemic-Selected Observations, "Journal of Modern Science" 2020, Vol. 45
https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3690197
Załucki M., Videotestament. Prawo spadkowe wobec nowych technologii, Warszawa 2018
Załucki M., Wills Formalities versus Testator's Intention. Functional Model of Effective Testation for Informal Wills, Nomos 2021
https://doi.org/10.5771/9783748924722
Załucki M., Współczesne tendencje rozwoju ustawodawstwa testamentowego, "Roczniki Nauk Prawnych" 2012, Vol. 2
Załucki M. (ed.), Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz, Warszawa 2019
Zimmermann R., Testamentsformen: "Willkür" oder Ausdruck einer Rechtskultur ?, "Rabels Zeitschrift für ausländisches und internationales Privatrecht" 2012, Vol. 76
https://doi.org/10.1628/003372512801786881