en

The Hans Island Dispute and the Doctrine of Occupation

2016, 68, No. 1

Uniwersytet Warszawski, Wydział Prawa i Administracji, Instytut Historii Prawa, Katedra Europejskiej Tradycji Prawnej

DOI

-

Publication date

20.03.2017

Publishing model

open access

License type


Field

Law

Discipline

law

Language of publication

English

Downloads

PDF 359 KB

Article

Number of views:93

Number of downloads:18

Crossref citations:0

Altmetric score:0


Abstract

The tiny Hans Island, claimed by both Canada and Denmark, is the latest disputed land in Arctic. The aim of this article is to analyse whether this sovereignty question can be resolved by referring to the doctrine of occupation. The methods used are historical analysis and the dogmatics of international law. The historical examples and doctrinal views lead to the first level conclusion that in certain circumstances a land that belongs to no one can be occupied by a state merely by means of symbolic actions. Further considerations focus on the questions of whether Hans Island should be considered as possessing such certain qualities and if so, whether any of the contestants has ever performed any actions that can be interpreted as taking it into its possession. The conclusion points out that although it is very unlikely that analyzed solutions would be used to determine the fate of the Island, it is still crucial to realise that doctrines of international law, which may seems archaic, are to some extent still applicable and could be used in the Arctic disputes.

Keywords:

Bibliography

Anonymous, Russia laiys claim to vast area of Arctic, “The Guardian”, August 4, 2015, accessed at https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/aug/04/russia-lays-claim-to¬-vast-areas-of-arctic-seabed (visited October 9, 2016)

Anonymous, The Arctic. Frozen Conflict. Denmark claims the North Pole, “The Economist”, December 20, 2014, accessed at http://www.economist.com/news/international/21636756-denmark-claims-north-pole-frozen-conflict (visited October 9, 2016)

Barkham P., Why does Denmark think it can lay claim to the north pole?, “The Guardian”, December 16, 2014, accessed at http://www.theguardian.com/world/shortcuts/2014/dec/16/why-denmark-thinks-it-can-lay-claim-to-north-pole on (visited October 9, 2016)

Boswell R., Hans Island was ours first, Greenland says, “Ottawa Citizen”, May 29, 2008, accessed at http://byers.typepad.com/arctic/2008/12/hans-island-was-ours-first-gre-enland-says.html (visited October 9, 2016)

Byers M., Baker J., International Law and the Arctic, Cambridge University Press 2013

Byers M., Creative thinking on sovereignty, July 3, 2014, accessed at http://byers.type-pad.com/arctic/2014/03/creative-thinking-on-sovereignty.html#more (visited Octo¬ber 9, 2016)

Cavell J., Historical Evidence and the Eastern Greenland Case, “Arctic” 2008, Vol. 61, No. 4

Cavell J., Sector Claims and Counter-Claims: Joseph Elzéar Bernier, the Canadian Government, and Arctic Sovereignty, 1898−1934, “Polar Record” 2014, Vol. 50, issue 3

Cavell J., Noakes J., Acts of Occupation. Canada and the Arctic Sovereignty 1918–25, University of British Columbia Press, Vancouver 2010

Dawes P. R., Tukiainen T., Hans Ø, celebrated island of Nares Strait between Greenland and Canada: from dogsledge to satellite mapping, “Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland Bulletin” 2008, Vol. 15

Frozen Conflict. Denmark claims the North Pole, “The Economist”, December 20, 2014 accessed at http://www.economist.com/news/international/21636756-denmark-claims-north-pole-frozen-conflict (visited October 9, 2016)

Garver R., Move Over, Santa: Putin Claims the North Pole, “The Fiscal Times”, August 6, 2015, accessed at http://www.cnbc.com/2015/08/06/move-over-santa-putin-cla¬ims-the-north-pole.html (visited October 9, 2016)

Goldie L. F. E., The Critical Date, “International and Comparative Law Quarterly” 1963, Vol. 12, issue 4

Grydehøj A., Grydehøj A., Ackrén M., The Globalization of the Arctic: Negotiating Sovereignty and Building Communities in Svalbard, Norway, “Island Studies Jour¬nal” 2012, Vol. 7, No. 1

Grydehøj A., Informal Diplomacy in Norway’s Svalbard Policy: The Intersection of Local Community Development and Arctic International Relations, “Global Change, Peace & Security” 2013, Vol. 26, No. 1

Harper K., Give it to Denmark, “The Globe and Mail”, July 27, 2005, accessed at http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/letters/give-it-to-denmark/article4119567/ (visited October 9, 2016)

Heffernan B., Our Navy’s show of force off Rockall, “Independent.ie”, October 13, 2012, accessed at http://www.independent.ie/irish-news/our-navys-show-of-force-off-roc¬kall-28892820.html (visited October 9, 2016)

Høyem T., Mr. Graham, you should have told us you were coming, “Globe and Mail”, July 29, 2005, accessed at http://byers.typepad.com/arctic/2008/11/mr-graham-you-should-have-told-us-you-were-coming.html#more (visited October 9, 2016)

Hyde Ch. C., The Case Concerning the Legal Status of Eastern Greenland, “The American Journal of International Law” 1933, Vol. 27, No. 4

Ibbitson J., Dispute over Hans Island nears resolution. Now for the Beaufort Sea, “Globe and Mail”, January 26, 2011, accessed at http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/politics/dispute-over-hans-island-nears-resolution-now-for-the-beaufort-sea/artic¬le563692/ (visited October 9, 2016)

Judicial Decision Involving Questions of International Law. France–Mexico, “The American Journal of International Law” 1932, Vol. 26, No. 2

Justinian, “Digest” (D. 41.1.3.pr) and “Institutions” (I. 2.1.12)

Kikkert P., Lackenbauer P. W., Legal Appraisals of Canada’s Arctic Sovereignty. Key Documents 1905–56, Center for Military and Strategic Studies, University of Calgary; Center of Foreign Policy and Federalism, St. Jerome Univeristy 2014, No. 2

Killaby G., “Great Game in Cold Climate”. Canada’s Arctic Sovereignty in Question, “Canadian Military Journal”, Winter 2005–2006

Kramer A. E., Russia Stakes New Claim to Expanse in the Arctic, “The New York Times”, August 4, 2015, accessed at http://www.nytimes.com/2015/08/05/world/eu¬rope/kremlin-stakes-claim-to-arctic-expanse-and-its-resources.html (visited Octo¬ber 9, 2016)

Kristensen P. E. D., Ambassador of Denmark, Letter to the Editor, “Ottawa Citizen”, July 28, 2005, accessed at http://byers.typepad.com/arctic/2009/02/hans-island-denmark¬-responds.html (visited October 9, 2016)

Lesaffer R., Argument from Roman Law in Current International Law: Occupation and Acquisitive Prescription, “The European Journal of International Law” 2005, Vol. 16

Mikkelsen O., Denmark to claim slice of continental shelf in Arctic Ocean, “Reuters”, December 15, 2016, accessed at http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/12/15/us-den¬mark-arctic-idUSKBN0JT0S620141215 (visited October 9, 2016)

Oppenheim L., Lauterpacht H., International Law. A Treatise, London–New York–To¬ronto 1958

Orent P., Reinsch P., Sovereignty over Islands in the Pacific, “The American Journal of International Law” 1941, Vol. 35, No. 3

PCIJ (Permanent Court of International Justice) 1933. Series A/B Judgments, orders and advisory opinions. Fascicule No. 53, Legal Status of Eastern Greenland

Royle S. A., “This Mere Speck in the Surface of the Waters”: Rockall Aka Waveland, “Shima: The International Journal of Research into Island Cultures” 2014, Vol. 8, No. 1

Russia laiys claim to vast area of Arctic, “The Guardian”, August 4, 2015, accessed at https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/aug/04/russia-lays-claim-to-vast-areas-of¬-arctic-seabed (visited October 9, 2016)

Shaw M. N., International Law, 5th ed., Cambridge University Press 2003

Skarstein F., Erik the Red’s Land: the land that never was, “Polar Research” 2006, Vol. 25, No. 2

Smedal G., Acquisition of Sovereignty over Polar Areas, “Skriften om Svalbard og Oshavet” 1931, Vol. 36

Stevenson Ch., Hans off!: The Struggle for Hans Island and the Potential Ramifications for International Border Dispute Resolution, “Boston College International & Com¬parative Law Review” 2007, Vol. 30

Truyol y Serra A., The Discovery of the New World and International Law, “University of Toledo Law Review” 1971, No. 43

Ulfstein G., The Svalbard Treaty. From Terra Nullius to Norwegian Sovereignty, Scandi-navian University Press, Oslo 1995

von der Heydte F. A., Discovery, Symbolic Annexation and Virtual Effectiveness in In-ternational Law, “The American Journal of International Law” 1935, Vol. 29, No. 3

von Glahn G., Law Among Nations. An Introduction to Public International Law, New York–London 1981

Wilkinson J. P., Gudmandsen P., Hanson S., Saldo R., Samelson R. M., Hans Island: Me-teorological Data From an International Borderline, “Eos” 2009, Vol. 90, issue 22

Similar publications