en

LEGAL CHANGE AND THE ROLE OF THE SCHOLAR: SCRATCHING BENEATH THE SURFACE OF COMPARATIVE TAXONOMIES

2023, 99, No. 1

Middlesex University, School of Law

University College London


Publication date

03.02.2024

Publishing model

open access

License type


Field

Law

Discipline

law

Language of publication

English

Downloads

PDF 472 KB

Article

Number of views:185

Number of downloads:44

Crossref citations:0

Altmetric score:0


Abstract

Both the classical theory of legal families and its more modern articulations place East European jurisdictions in the same box because they give precedence to their common socialist experience. Not only do they serve as distorting mirrors propelling stereotypes, but also they close off promising avenues of comparative research because of the politically tainted pre-understanding(s) of legal systems which they impose. This article argues that legal change is frequently facilitated by small groups of individuals who are often scholars. By paying closer attention to their role and incentives as well as the networks to which they belonged, we may see traditional categories realign and gain a more in-depth understanding of the patterns of legal change – namely, the intricate ways in which law evolves – and uncover little-known but important relationships between legal systems which comparative taxonomies either ignore or fail to explain. The article illustrates its argument by zooming in on the role of three scholars – Lyuben Dikov, Filippo Vassalli, and Karl Llewellyn – who may hold the key to explaining interesting, but unexpected similarities between Bulgarian, Italian, and US law.

Keywords:

Bibliography

Ansaldi M., 'The German Llewellyn' (1992) 58 Brooklyn Law Review 705

Apostolov I., The Law of Obligations: General Part (3rd ed., Bulgarian Academy of Sciences 1990)

Camero J., 'Mission Impracticable: The Impossibility of Commercial Impracticability' (2015) 13 University of New Hampshire Law Review 1

https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2449566

Casebeer K., 'Escape from Liberalism: Fact and Value in Karl Llewellyn' (1977) Duke Law Journal 671

https://doi.org/10.2307/1371956

Chiodi G., 'Filippo Vassalli' in Enciclopedia italiana di scienze, lettere ed arti. Il contributo italiano alla storia del pensiero - Diritto (Treccani 2012) 563

David R., Les grands systèmes de droit contemporains (Dalloz 1964)

Dikov L., Das Institut des Strohmannes (die vorgeschobene Person) im bürgerlichen Rechte (Doctoral Thesis, Göttingen 1922)

Dikov L., 'Die Abänderung von Verträgen den Richter' in Hedemann-Festschrift (Jena 1938)

Dikov L., and Hedemann J.W., Die Neugestaltung des deutschen bürgerlichen Rechts (Duncker & Humblot 1937)

Dikov L., 'Il Diritto civile dell'avvenire' (1931) 11 Rivista internazionale di filosofia del diritto 153

Dikov L., Morality and Law (Imprimerie de la Cour 1934).

Dikov L., 'Norma giuridica e volontà privata' (1934) 14 Rivista internazionale di filosofia del diritto 681

Dikov L., 'The Essence of Adjudication' in The Modification of Contracts by the Judge (first published 1923, Feneya 2010) 144

Dikov L., 'The Evolution of Contract' (1938) 33 Annuaire de l'Université de Sofia 437

Dikov L., 'The New Italian Civil Code' (1942) 37 Annuaire de l'Université de Sofia 57

Dikov L., 'The Social Equilibrium. "Static" and "Dynamic" Law' (1939) 34 Annuaire de l'Université de Sofia 1

Ferri G., Filippo Vassalli O Il Diritto Civile Come Opera d'Arte (CEDAM 2002)

Gotsev V., 'La diffusion du droit italien en Bulgarie' in Annuario di diritto comparato e di studi legislative (Edizioni scientifiche italiane 2014)

Graziadei M., 'Comparative Law as the Study of Transplants and Receptions' in Reinhard Zimmermann and Mathias Reimann (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Law (Oxford University Press 2006) 442

https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199296064.013.0014

Graziadei M., 'Comparative Law, Legal History, and the Holistic Approach to Legal Cultures' (1999) 7 Zeitschrift für Europäisches Privatrecht 531

Hawkland W., 'The Energy Crisis and Section 2-615 of the Uniform Commercial Code' (1974) 79 Commercial Law Journal 75

Husa J., A New Introduction to Comparative Law (Hart Publishing 2015)

https://doi.org/10.5040/9781849469531

Husa J., 'Legal Families and Research in Comparative Law' (2001) 3 Global Jurist Advances 1

https://doi.org/10.2202/1535-1661.1041

Janssen A. and Schultze R., 'Legal Cultures and Legal Transplants in Germany' (2011) 2 European Review of Private Law 225

https://doi.org/10.54648/ERPL2011014

Kelemen K. and Fekete B., 'How Should the Legal Systems of Eastern Europe be Classified Today?' (International Conference for the 10th Anniversary of the Institute of Comparative Law, Potsdam, 2014)

Lef A.A., 'Unconscionability and the Code: The Emperor's New Clause' (1967) 115 University of Pennsylvania Law Review 485

https://doi.org/10.2307/3310882

Llewellyn K., 'Law and the Modern Mind: A Symposium' (1931) 31 Columbia Law Review 82

https://doi.org/10.2307/1115265

Llewellyn K., 'Law and the Social Sciences - Especially Sociology' (1949) 62 Harvard Law Review 1286

Llewellyn K., The Bramble Bush (Oceana Publications 1951).

Llewellyn K., 'What Price Contract? - An Essay in Perspective' (1931) 40 Yale Law Journal 704

https://doi.org/10.2307/790659

MacMahon P., 'Good Faith and Fair Dealing as an Underenforced Legal Norm' (2015) 99

https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2501246

Minnesota Law Review 2051

Mattei U., 'Three Patterns of Law: Taxonomy and Change in the World's Legal Systems' (1997) 45 American Journal of Comparative Law 5

https://doi.org/10.2307/840958

McKendrick E., 'Force Majeure Clauses: The Gap between Doctrine and Practice' in Andrew Burrows and Edwin Peel (eds), Contract Terms (2nd edition, Oxford University Press 2009)

Mitchell P., 'Patterns of Legal Change' (2012) 65 Current Legal Problems 177

https://doi.org/10.1093/clp/cus008

Merryman J.H., 'The Italian Style II: Law' (1966) 18 Stanford Law Review 396

https://doi.org/10.2307/1227272

Monateri P.G. and Somma A., 'The Fascist Theory of Contract: A Comparative and Historical Inquiry into the Darker Side of Contract Law' (2009) Cardozo Electronic Law Bulletin http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1347692

Nillesen C., 'Keeping the Faith' (25 March & 1 April 2016) New Law Journal 12

Örücü E., 'A General View of "Legal Families" and of "Mixing Systems"' in Esin Örücü and David Nelken (eds), Comparative Law: A Handbook (Hart Publishing 2007) 169

Örücü E., 'Comparative Motley: Offerings from a Comparative Lawyer' (2022) 2 Critical Analysis of Law 8:2 (2021) 1

https://doi.org/10.33137/cal.v8i2.37852

Pédamon C., 'The Paradoxes of the Theory of Imprévision in the New French Law of Contract: A Judicial Deterrent?' (2017) Amicus Curiae: Journal of the Society for Advanced Legal Studies 10

https://doi.org/10.14296/ac.v2017i112.5041

Pothier R.J., Traité des obligations (Paris 1761).

Quigley J., 'Socialist Law and the Civil Tradition' (1989) 37 American Journal of Comparative Law 781

https://doi.org/10.2307/840224

Robinson O.F., Fergus T.D., Gordon W.M., European Legal History (3rd edition, Butterworths 2000)

Sassolas D., 'Les valeurs sociales et le Code civil' in Geneviève Pignarre (ed), Le droit des obligations d'un siècle à l'autre (Institut Universitaire Varenne 2016) 109

Tadjer V., Civil Law of People's Republic of Bulgaria: General Part. Section 1 (Nauka i izkustvo 1972)

Twining W., Karl Llewellyn and the Realist Movement (2nd edition, Cambridge University Press 2012)

https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139151085

Unification du Droit. Volume II (Unidroit 1951)

Unification du Droit. Volume III (Unidroit 1954)

Uzelac A., 'Survival of the Third Legal Tradition?' (2010) 49 Supreme Court Law Review (2d) 377

Vassalli F., 'Arte e vita nel diritto civile' in Studi Giuridici. Vol. 2 (Foro Italiano 1939)

Vassalli F., 'Motivi e caratteri della codificazione civile' in Studi Giuridici. Volume III (Giuffrè 1960)

Vassileva R., Bulgarian Private Law at Crossroads (Intersentia 2022)

https://doi.org/10.1017/9781839702969

Vassileva R., 'Shattering Myths: The Curious History of the Bulgarian Law of Obligations' (2019) 82 Studia Iuridica 309

https://doi.org/10.5604/01.3001.0013.9793

Vassileva R., 'Contract Law and the Social Contract: Rethinking Law Reform in the Field of Contract Law from the Perspective of Social Contract Theory' (2016) 11-III Pravni život 267

Venedikov P., Memories (2nd edition, Sibi 2018)

Winship P., 'Karl Llewellyn in Rome' (1998) 3 Uniform Law Review 725

https://doi.org/10.1093/ulr/3.2-3.725

Zweigert K. and Kötz H., Einführung in die Rechtsvergleichung auf dem Gebiete des Privatrechts (Mohr Siebeck 1969)

Zweigert K. and Kötz H., Introduction to Comparative Law (Tony Weir tr, 3rd edition, Clarendon Press

Similar publications